No bin store on Amelia Island? No problem. Within a two-hour radius — and stretching further for the true treasure hunters — there are warehouse-sized thrift destinations worth a dedicated road trip. From Orange Park to Lake Worth, these are the six spots Salt My Heart recommends, with everything you need to plan the run.
At a Glance
SuperThrift Jacksonville
The closest and highest-rated bin store to Amelia Island, SuperThrift on Blanding Blvd is the natural first stop for any treasure-hunting run. With a 4.8-star rating across nearly 800 reviews, it consistently delivers — a testament to both the quality of merchandise and the organization of the space.
This is the one to hit first on a multi-store trip, while you have fresh eyes and maximum trunk space. Come early on a Friday when the new stock has just been rolled out.
Friendly Bin Store
Head north into Georgia and the Friendly Bin Store in Savannah earns its name — high marks, a loyal following, and a daily pricing structure that rewards those who know how to work it.
Prices start at $6 on Fridays and Saturdays when new stock arrives, then drop each day until Thursday, when everything is $1 each. If you can plan a mid-week Savannah day trip, the math gets very compelling, very fast. Pair it with lunch in the Historic District and you've got a full excursion.
Florida Wholesale Liquidation
This one isn't your typical clothing-and-housewares thrift. Florida Wholesale Liquidation on US 441 specializes in big-ticket overstock and returns — appliances, flooring, tools, and hardware at up to 70% off retail. It's the stop for anyone outfitting a rental property, tackling a renovation, or setting up a full household on a budget.
The stock rotates with liquidation pallets, so no two visits are the same. Worth calling ahead if you're hunting for something specific, and bring a truck if there's any chance you'll score furniture or an appliance.
Goodwill Supercenter — Orange Blossom Trail
Supercenter-scale means supercenter inventory — over 1,200 reviews tells you this place gets serious foot traffic. Goodwill's South Orange Blossom Trail location in Orlando is built for volume: long hours, seven days a week, and a relentless stock rotation.
The 3.7 rating reflects the chaos that comes with scale. Come with a plan, a specific list, and patience. Buried in the bins is exactly the kind of haul that makes the drive worthwhile. Best suited as an overnight-trip stop — see Riverview below as a logical pairing.
Goodwill Riverview Supercenter
The Riverview Supercenter earns its place on this list for one reason above all: furniture. If you're hunting large pieces — sofas, dining sets, bedroom furniture — this is the Tampa-area location that consistently delivers quality finds at thrift prices.
Pair it with the Orlando location on an overnight trip: hit Orlando Day 1, stay near Tampa, hit Riverview Day 2 before heading home on I-75 or I-95. If you're going on a Wednesday and you qualify for the senior discount, even better.
GoodLife SuperThrift
At four and a half hours, GoodLife SuperThrift in Lake Worth is the farthest on this list — and the one for dedicated road-trippers only. But if you're already making a run down the coast, or combining it with a South Florida visit, it's worth adding to the itinerary.
GoodLife runs a rewards program, so frequent shoppers accumulate value over multiple visits. Proceeds benefit the American Cancer Society. Combine with Riverview and Orlando for the full south-Florida thrift circuit.
The Two-Day Thrift Road Trip
A structured run through the best stores, south of Amelia Island
Day 1 — Head South
- Morning stop: SuperThrift Orange Park (~45 min)
- Afternoon: Florida Wholesale Liquidation, Alachua (~1.5 hrs)
- Late afternoon: Goodwill Supercenter, Orlando (~2.5 hrs)
- Overnight near Orlando or Tampa
Day 2 — Tampa & Home
- Morning: Goodwill Riverview (~3 hrs from Amelia)
- Optional: GoodLife SuperThrift, Lake Worth (add 1.5 hrs)
- Return via I-95 north
What to Bring
🧂 Insider Tips from the Bins
- Friday = fresh stock. Most stores restock Thursday evening or Friday morning. First pick goes to the early crowd on Friday.
- Monday–Thursday = lowest prices. Daily markdown cycles mean mid-week shoppers pay the least, often $1–$3 per item.
- Scan everything. The Amazon seller app (or any barcode scanner) can tell you what an item is worth at retail in seconds. Don't rely on guessing.
- Inspect before you commit. Check all electronics for cords and damage, check furniture joints, open every latch. No returns at bin stores.
- Follow their Facebook pages. Many bin stores post "blue tag day" sales, special events, and new pallet arrivals on Facebook — worth a follow before you drive two hours.
- Target the rental furnishing goal. A full apartment's worth of furniture — couch, dining table, bed frame, dressers — is genuinely achievable under $500 on a well-planned multi-stop run.